Lightroom 6 / CC Performance Benchmarks

With the release of Lightroom 6 / CC, there has been a lot of hype about the performance speedups in image rendering. Being curious, I ran a few tests to see how much LR6/CC may have improved for my own workflow.

Summary

  • Processing and exporting from raw files is significantly faster in LR 6/CC (about 30%). The GPU did not make a difference.
  • No difference in generating previews between LR 5 and 6.
  • Small panoramas take roughly equivalent time in PS and Lightroom. But my test with a large panorama (18 images) was over 3x slower in LR than PS.
  • HDR takes about the same time in LR or PS (slight edge to PS).
  • Plugins that access the underlying database may be slower. For example, Metadata Wrangler, which I use to export metadata to a CSV file was twice as slow in LR6 compared to LR5

Note that the HDR and Panorama algorithms in LR 6 are not exactly equivalent to their PS counterparts. For example, LR generates a 16 bit HDR file whereas PS is 32 bit.

Setup

I ran tests on my late 2013 retina Macbook Pro with 16GB RAM, Nvidia Geforce GT 750M gpu, and the Lightroom catalog on the internal SSD. The image files were on an external 3 disk thunderbolt RAID-0 stripe.

The images for testing were my own edited RAW files with the majority being 21MP captures from a Canon 5d Mark II. Timing done manually (so don’t expect times to be more accurate than +/- 1 second).

Results

Lightroom 5 vs 6: Export jpegs from raws

Lightroom 5 vs 6/CC: Generate Previews

Lightroom 6/CC vs PS: Generate HDR

The above graph is based on 3 test HDR images. The first two involve a 3 image set taken with 2 stop brackets. The third image involves 8 bracketed images at 1 stop.

Note that both LR and PS create HDR images in 2 steps: in the first the images are loaded and a preview (LR only) is generated. In the second, a full size HDR is generated.

Lightroom 6/CC vs PS: Generate Panorama

Note that LR generates a panorama in two steps: (1) preview generation, and (2) full size rendering. In contrast, PS generates the final panorama in one step.

LR and PS took comparable times for the two smaller panoramas (5 and 9 images), however the third panorama (with 18 images) was much slower in LR. Also, preview generation took the majority of time making that step less useful (one might as well generate the final image). Ideally for larger panoramas we would like the preview to be quick so that we can decide whether it is worth the time to fully process the composite image.

Lightroom 5 vs 6/CC: Export metadata to CSV file with plugin

The above graph is based on exporting metadata such as keywords, captions, dimensions, etc from the image files into a CSV file. For this, I used Jeffry Friedl’s Metadata Wrangler plugin.

The times in the graph are based on processing 7326 images (everything I have on my website). Lightroom 6 is substantially slower than 5 so there may be some changes behind the Lightroom SDK for plugin developers.

Lightroom 5 vs 6/CC: Compute image hashes with plugin

The above graph is based on my Validator plugin for verifying RAW files based on hashes. This test involves computing MD5 hashes via the Lightroom SDK on 7326 images and comparing to previously stored values. No difference in timing here.

Making a Mobile Friendly Photography Website

Back in February, Google announced that they were going to use mobile friendliness as a ranking factor for websites: Starting April 21, we will be expanding our use of mobile-friendliness as a ranking signal. This change will affect mobile searches in all languages worldwide and will have a significant impact in our search results. Basically…

Read More »

Passing Google's mobile friendly test.

Why Images Appear Blurry on Retina and Hi-DPI Screens

When I moved my main machine to a retina Macbook Pro, I was surprised to notice that the screen made my website images appear blurry. I had thought image sharpness would stay the same (or improve) since the physical resolution of the screen was much higher. I also thought that any resampling by the browser…

Read More »

Safari, Chrome, and Preview (Mac native viewer) of non-retina images on a retina display.

OWC ThunderBay 4 Thunderbolt Enclosure Review

The OWC ThunderBay 4 is a Thunderbolt 2 hard disk enclosure that holds up to 4 drives. The enclosure does not have hardware RAID support (although this is possible with software) and the disks appear individually to the operating system. In other words this is a JBOD (“just a bunch of disks”) enclosure. Note that…

Read More »

benchmark-blackmagic

Serendipity at Santa Monica Beach

I normally think about photography in terms of making pictures, where one carefully plans out the composition and light, but sometimes you just get lucky and a photo just appears in front of your camera. For this picture, I had setup on Santa Monica beach with the intention of photographing the pier and ferris wheel…

Read More »

Couple at walking at sunset on Santa Monica beach.

Last Night in Prague

I took this photo on my last night in Prague. Before visiting the city, I came up with a shooting list and I knew that I want to create some iconic images of Prague’s bridges. I had already shot the Charles bridge but hadn’t yet seen a good location where I could have multiple bridges…

Read More »

Light trails and Prague Bridges.

Baby Sea Turtle Struggles to Reach the Ocean

Went I went to Costa Rica, one of the events I was very lucky to witness was the hatching of baby sea turtles on Tortuguero Beach and watching them make the long crawl from their nest to the ocean. Tortuguero is the largest Atlantic nesting site of the endangered green turtle. Green sea turtles nest…

Read More »

Newly hatched baby Atlantic Green Sea Turtle struggles to reach the ocean. Tortuguero, Costa Rica.